Crystalline Silica (CS) in “after use” HTIW products

  • Some forms of silica are used in the manufacture of HTIW products, however Crystalline Silica (CS) is not present in any products as sold and installed.
  • When amorphous HTIW products are used in high temperature applications, depending on time and temperature different stable crystalline phases may form including CS. This process is called devitrification
  • HTIW products at the end of their useful life, having been subjected to prolonged high temperatures and devitrification processes, are referred to as „after use“
  • IARC classified CS when inhaled in the form of quartz or cristobalite dust from occupational sources as a Group 1 carcinogen.
  • Silica related fibrosis and cancer in humans have most clearly been observed following exposures to freshly cleaved respirable free silica dust
  • In after use HTIW products, CS can be present in the form of crystals that are embedded in a matrix of other crystals and glasses
  • Scientific studies (in-vivo and in-vitro) on after use fibres have shown no effects related to the presence of CS

Refractory materials, including bricks, castables and man-made mineral fibre products, are usually composed of silicates – silicon in various combinations with oxygen and other elements. Most HTIWs consist of amorphous glass fibres. Although forms of silica may be used in their manufacture, none of these contain any free CS in the product as sold and installed.

EU adopted BOELV in 2017 for process generated, respirable, crystalline silica dust

In making their overall evaluation, the IARC Working Group noted that carcinogenicity in humans was not detected in all industrial circumstances. Carcinogenicity may be dependent on inherent characteristics of the CS or on external factors affecting its biological activity or distribution of its polymorphs.

When, in the 1980’s, ASW/RCF’s were tested in a series of animal experiments (the so-called RCC studies), the samples tested included a specimen of heated (devitrified or crystallised) ASW/RCF, estimated as containing 27 % cristobalite, to simulate after use fibres. This sample caused less lung effects than any other sample tested and no excess of tumours. These early results with ASW/RCF already gave an indication that (devitrified) end of life fibres do not constitute a health hazard. Further studies at the IOM in Edinburgh also found this sample to be inert when injected into the peritoneum of rats.

Recently in vitro studies carried out at Fraunhofer Institute for Toxicology and Experimental Medicine and Heriot Watt University on simulated after service fibres, showed that no toxicity can be linked to the formation of CS in the fibres. Papers detailing these studies can be found below.

Research Article

Assessing the bioactivity of crystalline silica in heated high-temperature insulation wools.

Read more
Research Article

Lack of marked cyto- and genotoxicity of cristobalite in devitrified (heated) alkaline earth silicate wools in short-term assays with cultured primary rat alveolar macrophages.

read more
Review

Crystalline silica in heated man-made vitreous fibres

read more
Silica related fibrosis and cancer in humans have most clearly been observed following exposures to freshly cleaved respirable free silica dust. In after use HTIW, the CS is embedded in a matrix of other crystals and glasses and does not seem to be biologically available or capable of damaging the lung.

This, coupled with the inability to detect airborne CS during most after use activities (e.g. during furnace maintenance or wrecking), means that there is unlikely to be any risk of CS related disease associated with exposure to after use fibres.

Important Fact

AES and ASW may transform into a mixture of crystalline phases, but other Low Biopersistent fibres and PCW do not contain CS even after use.

ECFIA Action on Crystalline Silicia

Download and read more detailed information on Crystalline Silica in HTIW products after use in high temperature applications.

englishgermanfrench